# How Lawyers Give Candid Risk Advice Clients Can Hear

- Published: 2026-11-16
- Author: [Lawyer Magazine](https://lawyermagazine.co/author/lawyermagazine-co.md)
- Topics: [Q&A](https://lawyermagazine.co/qa.md)
- Source: https://lawyermagazine.co/qa/how-lawyers-give-candid-risk-advice-clients-can-hear/
- Publication: Lawyer Magazine
- Publisher: Connectively (Terkel, Inc.)
- Editorial policy: https://lawyermagazine.co/editorial-policy/
- AI use: The perspectives in this article were written by the named contributors and submitted through Connectively. Connectively's automated system selected them and used AI to write the headline, introduction, section headings, summary sections, and illustration, and to make minor edits for clarity. Articles are assembled and published automatically. Report errors to corrections@connectively.us.

### Let Data Reveal Financial Ruin

In my three decades of navigating Chapter 11 bankruptcies and high-net-worth divorces in Chicago, the most dangerous client is never the one who is confused; it is the one driven by ego to execute a financially suicidal strategy. Frequently, a business owner will demand to drain an ERISA-protected retirement account to prop up a failing commercial enterprise, or a spouse will want to burn fifty thousand dollars in legal fees to win a twenty-thousand-dollar asset purely out of spite. They view their desired course of action as a moral crusade. I view it as an unhedged, catastrophic liability.

When handling a client who demands unnecessary legal or business risk, I never tell them they are making a foolish choice. Telling a proud CEO or a betrayed spouse that their strategy is irrational instantly triggers defensiveness and destroys the professional relationship. Instead, I use a conversational framework I call "The Mathematics of Ruin." I completely remove my personal legal opinion from the room and force the client to argue directly with the digital architecture of their own destruction.

I project a blank spreadsheet onto the conference room wall and ask them to dictate their exact strategy to me. We build the financial model of their desired path in real-time. We input the aggressive litigation costs, the severe tax penalties of early withdrawal, the statutory interest rates, and the statistical probability of courtroom sanctions. We let the algorithms calculate the final, devastating output. I then turn to the client and say, "I work for you, and I am fully capable of executing this offensive. However, before I file the paperwork, you must sign a directive acknowledging that this specific path mathematically guarantees your insolvency within eight months."

This approach preserves the relationship because it externalises the threat. I am no longer the restrictive lawyer telling them what they cannot do. The U.S. Bankruptcy Code, the tax regulations, and compounding interest become the adversaries. By shifting the conversation from a highly emotional legal debate into a cold, sterile mathematical audit, the client's ego is neutralised. They sit on the same side of the table as me, staring at the catastrophic data, and almost immediately ask how we can pivot back to the structural, risk-averse solution I originally proposed.

<aside class="expert"><img src="https://featured-com-images.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/profile-images/a00f2bda-d725-4211-9368-a45827f316ac.webp" alt="Loretta Kilday" loading="lazy"><p><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/lorettakilday/" rel="nofollow">Loretta Kilday</a>, DebtCC Spokesperson, <a href="https://www.debtconsolidationcare.com" rel="noopener">Debt Consolidation Care</a></p></aside>

---

### Stage the Outage Ahead of Disaster

1\. I say "no" to the plan, not to the client. I said "no" to launching MT5 on a single server in a cheap facility with no failover and no offsite backups last year to save about $1,400 per month. I suggested two alternative plans that would have cost about that much more to set up. A warm standby in a second data center would have cost more to set up than a minimal solution that had all the trade information replicated. I never argue against a plan by labeling it "risky" or "unsafe." I come up with numbers that oppose the broker's numbers. If they still want to go with the risky plan, I get their signed decision with the spelled out risks to us both. Usually that plan ends up not being so cheap after all.

2\. Write incident report before the incident occurs. Recently I presented to a broker a hypothetical post-mortem of a failure to close open positions of 600 clients when a disk controller fails on an NFP Friday at 13:30 GMT. 80 pips moved in the wrong direction while all trade actions were unable to complete. The resulting compensation claims, chargebacks, trade logs lost for a regulator inquiry and a failed to meet liquidity provider questions would stem from one failed disk controller. I asked the broker who would have to call their clients in such a failure. He didn't know in about 10 minutes but then agreed to a fully redundant architecture. This worked because I didn't tell them that they were wrong. Their timeline told them that. I was simply helping them to understand what they had already said about their worst day. They trusted me more after this conversation.

<aside class="expert"><img src="https://featured-com-images.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/profile-images/299e9201-111e-4433-ae2c-04eb367ce42d.webp" alt="Ace Zhuo" loading="lazy"><p><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/ace-zhuo" rel="nofollow">Ace Zhuo</a>, CEO | Sales and Marketing, Tech &amp; Finance Expert, <a href="https://www.tradingfxvps.com" rel="noopener">TradingFXVPS</a></p></aside>

---

### Pursue Objectives Without Compliance Peril

It is never a good idea to simply go along with any proposed undertaking by a client that one knows to be genuinely dangerous merely to avoid any confrontation. Giving in and doing it could lead to disastrous results, and at that moment it would be upsetting to hear the client say, "But you asked for it." The price of such untruthfulness in business and client relations may be rather high.

Note that this way of looking at the situation can be very useful. When speaking about it, I start with the client's goal instead of my objections. Rather than immediately saying "No, you don't want to do that," I say: "I know what you want, and I want to help you achieve your goal, but here's the risk I see with this course of action." Nonetheless, I make sure to keep on talking about ways to achieve the sought-after objective without risking failure.

For a legal client who required marketing text that was likely to break compliance rules, framing it as "this could turn into a serious problem for your company, let's deliver you the same results minus the risks" made a potential conflict into their gratitude for identifying the issue.

Sasha Berson Co-Founder and Chief Growth Executive at Grow Law

<aside class="expert"><img src="https://featured-com-images.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/profile-images/8a7e81e1-b2d0-4048-904b-2d300c966171.webp" alt="Sasha Berson" loading="lazy"><p><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/aleksanderberson" rel="nofollow">Sasha Berson</a>, Grow Chief Executive, <a href="https://growlaw.co" rel="noopener">Grow Law</a></p></aside>

---

### Challenge Choices With Future Scrutiny

I've learned that clients don't always need someone to agree with their decisions; they need someone willing to tell them what they might be overlooking.

When a client proposes a course of action that creates unnecessary legal or business risk, I avoid immediately telling them they're wrong. Instead, I walk them through a realistic scenario of what could happen, the potential financial and legal consequences, and what alternatives are available.

One approach that has worked particularly well is asking, "If this decision were challenged six months from now, would you be comfortable defending it?" It shifts the conversation from disagreement to risk assessment. Clients appreciate honesty when they understand it's coming from a desire to protect their long-term interests.

<aside class="expert"><img src="https://featured-com-images.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/profile-images/f2cc51f6-fe85-43b1-ad5a-6ab93642876e.webp" alt="Ed Hones" loading="lazy"><p><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/edward-hones/" rel="nofollow">Ed Hones</a>, Attorney At Law, <a href="https://www.honeslaw.com" rel="noopener">Hones Law Employment Lawyers PLLC</a></p></aside>

---

### Discover What Matters Most

When a client pushes for a strategy I don't recommend, I try to identify what they're really hoping to accomplish. Sometimes they want to clear their name quickly, regain some control, or make sure someone hears their side of the story. Those are understandable goals, but their preferred approach may not get them there. I ask what outcome matters most to them, then look for a safer way to pursue it. That changes the conversation from an argument about what they should or shouldn't do into a discussion about how we can work toward the same goal.

<aside class="expert"><img src="https://featured-com-images.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/profile-images/70b9b849-7016-44be-8086-cc8d35918465.webp" alt="Chris Walsh" loading="lazy"><p><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/chris-walsh-a460b4168/" rel="nofollow">Chris Walsh</a>, Criminal Defense Attorney, <a href="https://www.walshcriminaldefense.com" rel="noopener">Walsh Law</a></p></aside>

---

### Clarify Hazards and Present a Safer Route

When a client's preferred path creates unnecessary legal or business risk, I address it directly and early, and I explain the risk in plain terms so they can make an informed decision. I also ask for complete honesty and transparency, because missing details can turn a manageable issue into a much bigger problem later. From there, I offer a clear alternative strategy that protects their goals while reducing exposure, and I set realistic expectations about what each option could mean in the short and long term. I keep the conversation focused on shared objectives, not blame, so the client feels supported rather than judged. That combination of transparency and smart planning is how you protect the relationship while steering them away from avoidable risk.

<aside class="expert"><img src="https://featured-com-images.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/profile-images/263e5f84-8d2c-4506-9c9e-950bf9dbe851.webp" alt="Jamie E. Wright" loading="lazy"><p><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/jamie-e-wright-6a5108129" rel="nofollow">Jamie E. Wright</a>, LA Litigator &amp; Founder/CEO, <a href="https://jamiewrightesq.com" rel="noopener">The Wright Law Firm</a></p></aside>

---

### Demonstrate Your Damages Assessment

In personal injury law, clients sometimes come to an initial consultation with a settlement figure already in mind. That number may have little connection to the actual damages, available insurance coverage, or evidence supporting the claim. I try to address those expectations early rather than allowing disappointment to develop later. I'll explain how I evaluate damages and why certain factors carry more weight than others.

Clients tend to respond well when I show them how I reached my assessment instead of simply telling them their expectations are too high. Transparency makes difficult conversations much easier.

<aside class="expert"><img src="https://featured-com-images.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/profile-images/9eaf4cbe-0dfa-4dff-b7be-3ddd723a1135.webp" alt="Loren Schwartz" loading="lazy"><p><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/loren-schwartz-5a649640/" rel="nofollow">Loren Schwartz</a>, Attorney, <a href="https://www.rftmlaw.com" rel="noopener">Rouda Feder Tietjen &amp; McGuinn</a></p></aside>

---

### Balance Emotional Stakes Against Financial Impact

Divorce can bring out a level of frustration that people don't necessarily recognize in themselves. I've had conversations where a client wanted to spend significant time and money fighting over something that had very little impact on their financial future or relationship with their children. In such cases, I try to bring the discussion back to what they're actually trying to accomplish. I'll ask them to consider whether the potential benefit justifies the financial and emotional cost. Seeing those two things side by side can change the entire conversation. So, sometimes, my job is just to help people find outcomes they can live with.

<aside class="expert"><img src="https://featured-com-images.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/profile-images/edb9bf82-2959-4e8a-a606-0dea56da3c95.webp" alt="Judith Sadler" loading="lazy"><p><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/judithsadler" rel="nofollow">Judith Sadler</a>, Managing Shareholder, <a href="https://www.texasadvocates.com" rel="noopener">Diggs &amp; Sadler</a></p></aside>

---

### Anchor Projects to Shared Commitments

When a client proposes a shortcut that raises business risk, I first ask what outcome they need. A faster launch can be a sound goal, while the route to it may expose the project to failure. I explain what could go wrong, when we'd discover it and what correcting it would demand of the team. If the concern is legal exposure, I send that question to the client's counsel; our engineering view doesn't substitute for legal advice.

I put the desired outcome beside the proposed route and offer a workable alternative. For a launch deadline, I might suggest moving a feature to the next release while keeping checks on the core flow. The client gets a choice about scope while we can speak candidly about the consequences of the shortcut. At kickoff, we discuss the product's purpose and priorities, then agree on success criteria, risks and constraints. Our tech lead checks feasibility before work begins. When a request later puts an agreed goal at risk, we can refer to that goal instead of arguing over tastes or motives.

Critical decisions need written client confirmation, and work outside the agreed scope requires written approval. Silence isn't consent. If the client chooses another route after we've explained the tradeoff, we record their decision, its effect on the plan and what we can responsibly deliver. We still deliver what we've already committed to, without tying that work to acceptance of an additional proposal.

Candid advice preserves the relationship when we offer a feasible choice and leave the decision to the client. State the safer option with the same specificity as the risky route, including the feature or checks affected. Then get the decision in writing, so the next phase starts from terms both sides understand.

<aside class="expert"><img src="https://featured-com-images.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/profile-images/732f12d1-adb0-47c4-a0fb-1f2666e046c2.webp" alt="Roman Surikov" loading="lazy"><p><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/roman-surikov" rel="nofollow">Roman Surikov</a>, Founder &amp; CEO, <a href="https://ronasit.com" rel="noopener">Ronas IT | Software Development Company</a></p></aside>

---

### Connect Tradeoffs to Customer Outcomes

As an owner in custom manufacturing I deal with a version of this often. A customer will sometimes push for a choice we know will not turn out the way they expect, like fitting very fine text or detail onto a small pin, or squeezing an order into a deadline that leaves no room for proofing. Going along with it might feel easier in the moment, but it usually ends with a disappointed customer.

The approach that works best is tying the concern back to their goal instead of my preference. Rather than saying no, I would say something like, if you want people to read this from across a room, here is what will get you there, and here is the tradeoff if you stick with the original plan. That keeps the conversation about their outcome and gives them the final call with the full picture. Most customers appreciate the honesty, and the ones who move forward anyway know we were straight with them, which makes it easier to work through things together later.

<aside class="expert"><img src="https://featured-com-images.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/profile-images/b07b77c8-3a69-4bf5-8127-29611c67d6bc.webp" alt="Eric Turney" loading="lazy"><p><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/eric-turney" rel="nofollow">Eric Turney</a>, President / Sales and Marketing Director, <a href="https://www.montereycompany.com" rel="noopener">The Monterey Company</a></p></aside>

---

### Document Permissible Tax Routes

The client wanted to claim personal travel expenses as a business expense to lower his tax bill. When I asked him why he wanted to do this he said he wanted to lower the amount he had to pay.

I told him that if he was ever questioned about this he would have to pay for it and I wouldn't be able to back this up. I explained that there were two legal options available. I wrote a short e-mail outlining my concerns.

This helps to make the client think about why they are doing this and how they are doing this. Whilst it was correct that he wanted to lower the amount he was paying, he was going about this in the wrong way. By explaining that there was an issue with the way he was going about this, he could understand why without feeling like he was being pointed the finger.

He chose to take the other option. If he had pushed me I may not have worked with him however I have never had to find out.

<aside class="expert"><img src="https://featured-com-images.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/profile-images/629eef34-9ed7-4880-b2ef-32c751d56030.webp" alt="Ankit Sarawagi" loading="lazy"><p><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/ankit-sarawagi" rel="nofollow">Ankit Sarawagi</a>, Curator, <a href="https://cfomatrix.in" rel="noopener">CFO Matrix</a></p></aside>

---

### Compare Three Courses for Durable Decisions

When a client wants a course of action that creates unnecessary legal or business risk, I try to separate the goal from the tactic. I do not start with, "No, we can't do that." I start with, "I understand what outcome you want. Here is where I see the risk in this specific approach, and here are two safer ways to get close to the same result." That keeps the conversation focused on problem-solving instead of ego or confrontation.

One approach that has worked well for me in SaaS and digital product operations is what I think of as "decision framing." I lay out three options clearly: the requested path, a safer alternative, and a middle-ground option. For each one, I explain the likely upside, the operational downside, the reputational risk, and whether the short-term gain is worth the long-term cost. Clients usually respond better when they can see that I am not trying to block progress, but to help them make a durable decision.

A practical example is when someone wants to move faster than their process should allow, whether that is around content rights, user data handling, or aggressive campaign claims. In those moments, I try to be direct and calm: "My concern is not whether this can work today. My concern is whether it creates a preventable problem next month." That wording has helped preserve relationships because it shows alignment with the client's business outcome, not just opposition to the immediate idea.

I also think it is important to document the recommendation in plain language after the call. A short written recap with the risks, the preferred option, and the reason behind it reduces misunderstandings and gives the client room to reconsider without feeling publicly corrected.

The best client relationships I have had were strengthened, not damaged, by candid advice. Most serious clients may not love hearing "this is too risky," but they do value clarity, consistency, and the sense that you are protecting the business, not just reacting to a single request.

<aside class="expert"><img src="https://featured-com-images.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/profile-images/c0bb9f95-0813-4af5-93f8-2bdcbceac898.webp" alt="Kruno Sulić" loading="lazy"><p><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/krunosulic" rel="nofollow">Kruno Sulić</a>, Founder &amp; SaaS Product Builder, <a href="https://www.cliprise.app" rel="noopener">Cliprise</a></p></aside>

---

### Secure Proof Prior to Action

One of the most common situations I encounter involves clients who want to take action before they've preserved the evidence that could support their claims. They may want to confront management, announce their intentions, or send a lengthy explanation of everything they've experienced.

I understand the impulse, but those actions can sometimes complicate matters. I explain why preserving emails, text messages, performance reviews, and relevant employment records should come first. My approach is to explain what we could lose by acting too quickly rather than simply telling someone to slow down. Once clients understand the importance of protecting their evidence, they usually become more comfortable with a measured approach.

<aside class="expert"><img src="https://featured-com-images.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/profile-images/3bc0f01b-61c0-438a-9444-109801fc44ef.webp" alt="Omid Nosrati" loading="lazy"><p><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/omid-nosrati-2b178456" rel="nofollow">Omid Nosrati</a>, Founder, <a href="https://www.nosratilaw.com" rel="noopener">Nosrati Law</a></p></aside>

---

### Quantify the Downside in Writing

When a client wants something I think will hurt them, I stop arguing about the idea and start pricing the downside in their own numbers. Most of these requests in search marketing are the same few things: rebuild the whole site on a shiny new platform, delete old pages that look messy, or chase a quick trick a competitor seems to be getting away with. In my guide to Shopify blog SEO I wrote that I typically only recommend headless transitions for brands doing £20M+ GMV, because the maintenance cost and the risk of breaking critical SEO elements during the build are significant. That line exists because the conversation comes up so often.

The approach that keeps the relationship intact is a short written note before anything starts. It says what they asked for, what I think could go wrong, what I would watch, and what it would take to roll back. Then I ask them to decide. People push back on opinions, but they rarely push back on a list of the things that will break and who has to fix them.

Sometimes they still go ahead, and that is their call to make. The note means nobody is surprised later, and I get to be the person who flagged it calmly rather than the one saying I told you so.

<aside class="expert"><img src="https://featured-com-images.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/profile-images/bc1bfc93-3f05-4844-9d99-d83094b9ee8a.webp" alt="Christopher Coussons" loading="lazy"><p><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/chriscoussons" rel="nofollow">Christopher Coussons</a>, Director, <a href="https://visionary-marketing.co.uk" rel="noopener">Visionary Marketing</a></p></aside>

---

### Chart Benefits, Costs, and Reversibility

I have found that candid advice lands better when clients see the tradeoff in operational terms. Legal risk can feel distant, but lost flexibility, delayed decisions, damaged credibility, and unexpected expense are immediate business concerns.

A useful approach is to map three paths on a single page. The preferred path, the lower-risk alternative, and the consequence of doing nothing. Each path should include likely benefits, hidden costs, and the decision that would be hardest to reverse. This method replaces a lecture with a comparison. It also gives the client ownership of the final call while making the recommendation unmistakably clear.

<aside class="expert"><img src="https://featured-com-images.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/profile-images/c45151ff-5732-4de7-967f-7fe75284eee6.webp" alt="Reid Breitman" loading="lazy"><p><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/reid-breitman-7049a512a" rel="nofollow">Reid Breitman</a>, Personal Injury Lawyer, <a href="https://kuzyklaw.com" rel="noopener">Kuzyk Law Personal Injury &amp; Car Accident Lawyers</a></p></aside>

---

### Decline Hazardous Sales and Solve Distance

I tell them plainly that I will not help them do it, explain the risk in one sentence, and then offer the safe version of what they are trying to achieve. The classic request in my trade is a driver who wants to run a three-pin granny charger off a household extension lead because the socket is too far from the drive.

That setup asks a domestic lead to carry a heavy load for hours, often coiled and outdoors, which is how leads overheat. I do not lecture, and I do not pretend it is a grey area. I say that I am not willing to sell a product for that use, and that a charging cable or a properly installed outdoor socket solves the distance problem without the risk. Most people accept that, because they wanted a car that charges, not an argument about extension leads.

The conversation approach that keeps the relationship is starting from their goal rather than their plan. Asking how far the car sits from the socket and how many miles they drive a week turns a refusal into a solution. Every product on my shelf has to meet UK safety standards before it is listed, and I would rather lose a sale than be the shop that helped someone cut a corner with mains electricity.

<aside class="expert"><img src="https://featured-com-images.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/profile-images/1cba23c3-0d87-42a4-884a-a282c1e723ca.webp" alt="Jake Wardle" loading="lazy"><p><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/jake-wardle-942253262" rel="nofollow">Jake Wardle</a>, Founder, <a href="https://evcablehub.co.uk" rel="noopener">EV Cable Hub</a></p></aside>

---

### Use Buyer Insights to Concentrate Resources

When I disagree with a client's direction, I try to make the conversation about the business risk rather than whether their idea is right or wrong.

We faced this with Bifrost Defence, where there were potential buyers across six European markets. Trying to pursue every opportunity would have spread the team's resources too thin. Instead of simply advising them to narrow their focus, we used feedback from prospective buyers to show where the strongest opportunity was.

That helped us identify one initial market, a clearer buyer profile, and a specific use case to prioritize.

I've found that difficult advice is easier to accept when clients can see the reasoning behind it and understand what the alternative makes possible. You're not questioning their judgment. You're helping them make a more informed decision.

<aside class="expert"><img src="https://featured-com-images.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/profile-images/6b1817b9-6ebc-49cd-a6de-5472f512a44f.webp" alt="Melody Brooks" loading="lazy"><p><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/melodysb" rel="nofollow">Melody Brooks</a>, Founder, <a href="https://www.hitstride.co" rel="noopener">Stride Agency ApS</a></p></aside>

---

### Evaluate Words Through an Outsider's Lens

In contentious matters, a client may want a letter, email, or public response that feels decisive but creates a record better suited to the other side. Emotion often drives the request, especially after an insurer questions treatment or another party minimizes a loss. Dismissing that frustration can damage the relationship and obscure the legal concern.

I acknowledge the point the client wants made, then test the delivery method against a future reader who knows none of the history. Could the wording be read as an admission, retaliation, or unsupported accusation? That moves the discussion away from tone and toward consequences. A measured response, preserved chronology, or no response may hold greater strategic value. The concern remains valid, while the method is evaluated separately.

<aside class="expert"><img src="https://featured-com-images.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/profile-images/2984e3d7-02af-4def-b7bf-abd1dde21161.webp" alt="Chrissy Grigor" loading="lazy"><p><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/chrissygrigor" rel="nofollow">Chrissy Grigor</a>, Personal Injury Lawyer &amp; Founder, <a href="https://grigorlaw.com" rel="noopener">Grigor Law Injury &amp; Car Accident Lawyers</a></p></aside>

---

### Uncover Needs Behind Quick Fixes

I start by asking what they're really after. The risky idea is almost never the goal. It's a shortcut to the goal.

A client who wants to take the first offer usually doesn't care about the number. The bills are piling up and they need the stress to stop. A client who wants to post about the wreck on Facebook wants people to know what happened to them. A client who wants to stop going to physical therapy is tired of driving across town three times a week.

Once I know the real goal, I can tell them the truth about the risk without it sounding like I'm telling them no. The insurance company will read that post. The adjuster will use the gap in treatment to say you weren't really hurt. Then I give them another way to get what they want. We can talk to the medical providers about waiting on their bills. We can find a therapist closer to home.

People don't push back on advice that helps them get what they want. They push back when they feel like their lawyer isn't listening.

<aside class="expert"><img src="https://featured-com-images.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/profile-images/1519451a-738b-4e16-9393-7f67a2a88c7b.webp" alt="Adam Miller" loading="lazy"><p><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/adam-miller-348009437" rel="nofollow">Adam Miller</a>, Personal Injury Attorney, <a href="https://www.texasbulldoglaw.com" rel="noopener">The Miller Law Firm - Home of The Texas Bulldog</a></p></aside>

---

### Trace Contract Terms to Real Consequences

I start by finding out what the client is actually trying to achieve, because the risky course is usually a shortcut to something reasonable. A client who wants to skip a clause or sign fast almost always has a deadline or a relationship behind it, and I'd rather deal with that than argue about the clause.

After 15 years of drafting contracts, I've learned that "don't do that" ends the conversation and "here's what happens if you do" keeps it going. So I describe the risk in the client's own terms: the term that would let a counterparty walk away, the obligation that leaves them exposed, the deadline they'd miss. I don't recite rules at them. I trace the consequence to the thing they care about, and I do it in plain words, because a client who doesn't follow the explanation will just feel lectured.

Then I bring a second route to the same goal. There's usually one, and it costs a bit more time or a slightly weaker negotiating position. A client who is offered an alternative doesn't feel overruled; they feel they have a choice, and that changes how the rest of the conversation goes.

If they still choose the risky course, that's their decision to make. I write down what I advised and what they decided, and I draft the best version of what they asked for. Doing the work properly after I've disagreed matters more than winning the argument. It keeps the relationship honest, and the record protects both of us if the risk ever materialises.

Candour only works if the client can see you're still on their side.

<aside class="expert"><img src="https://featured-com-images.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/profile-image/7605e316-2c0e-49e9-a9db-f65c24e0be7d.webp" alt="Julie Nass" loading="lazy"><p><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/julie-nass-447591299" rel="nofollow">Julie Nass</a>, Legal Writer, <a href="https://eurekalegal.au" rel="noopener">EurekaLegal.au</a></p></aside>

---

### Echo Concerns, Then Give Counsel

As a personal injury attorney, I've had clients who want to pursue a certain course of action, defendant, or strategy that creates unnecessary legal or business risk. The most common scenarios are clients who want to pursue a defendant who lacks the means to pay a significant judgment, or wants to pursue a claim that is unlikely to succeed, or wants to decline a reasonable settlement offer in hopes of recovering more. In some ways, a conversation with a client with whom you disagree is like a negotiation. As with any negotiation, it is important to listen to the other side, to make concessions where possible, to clearly communicate your position and reasons, and to remain firm on your bottom line. If the client believes you are not hearing their concerns, trying to force their hand, or waffling, then they can lose trust, or in some cases, believe they can sway you. One approach is to repeat back the client's concerns and position: "I hear you saying \[x\]. I understand why you're saying \[x\]. I also want you to recover as much as possible. I've carefully considered this option, and here's what I've found...."

<aside class="expert"><img src="https://featured-com-images.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/profile-image/1792a635-e69a-42ff-ae31-981ad38ed52c.webp" alt="Conor Hulburt" loading="lazy"><p><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/conorhulburt/" rel="nofollow">Conor Hulburt</a>, Attorney, <a href="https://www.hulburtlaw.com/" rel="noopener">Hulburt Law Firm APC</a></p></aside>

---

### Ask Who Handles the Aftermath

When I ran my IT firm in Hamburg, a social work charity sent us a shopping list of six PCs, monitors and a storage box for a grant application. I asked who would look after it all, and the answer was "nobody really". I turned down the hardware-only sale and offered a cyber risk review for a symbolic 99 euros plus a fixed monthly support plan. Asking who owns the problem afterwards lets clients see the risk themselves, so nobody feels lectured.

Jens Hagel, Co-Founder, Yupana (Hamburg, Germany)

<aside class="expert"><img src="https://featured-com-images.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/profile-images/1493646b-6b57-4156-9cbc-f3deb86a5e51.webp" alt="Jens Hagel" loading="lazy"><p><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/jens-hagel-77671549" rel="nofollow">Jens Hagel</a>, Co-Founder, <a href="https://www.yupana.de" rel="noopener">Yupana</a></p></aside>

---

### Teach Procedure to Shape Defense

Managing a client who requests a course of action for his or her case which I believe to be unnecessary, or risky, is always difficult.

In my experience, there is no substitute for sitting down with the client and explaining the rules of the road.

Our laws can be very complex and even Byzantine at times. Explaining to the client the nuts and bolts of legal principles can be helpful. Beginning with basic criminal procedure and following through to the rules of hearsay, once a client understands for example, that we cannot use hearsay to defend them, and that we need live witnesses who can come to court to testify to what they saw or heard.

It is essential to explain to the client that the presumption of innocence is there to protect them; that it is very risky for a defendant to take the witness stand in their own defense when they could be cross-examined on issues that are detrimental to their credibility.

I have learned not to take for granted that my clients have seen all the things I've seen in 37 years of practice. That is why I begin with the basics and explain carefully how we will go through the criminal justice system advancing our cause without compromising ourselves.

<aside class="expert"><img src="https://featured-com-images.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/profile-images/035519c8-fa42-4661-8a6a-be9854667001.webp" alt="Jose Fanego" loading="lazy"><p><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/jose-fanego-25ba459a" rel="nofollow">Jose Fanego</a>, Attorney, <a href="https://josefanego.com" rel="noopener">The Law Offices of José R. Fanego</a></p></aside>

---

### Reject Unlawful Requests and Propose Legitimate Methods

As a private investigator, I frequently encounter clients who request things they see on television and assume are part of my job. They sometimes expect me to tap cell phones, install GPS trackers on vehicles, enter properties without permission, or use other investigative techniques that cross legal boundaries.

I usually explain that these activities are illegal, could jeopardize my private investigator's license, and potentially expose both of us to legal consequences. Most clients understand, but occasionally someone will continue to push.

When that happens, I turn the conversation around and put it into their perspective. I explain that the same laws they are asking me to circumvent are also there to protect them. They wouldn't want someone secretly tracking their vehicle, tapping their phone, or entering their property without permission. Those protections apply equally to everyone.

I then focus on what I can legally do to accomplish their objectives. I believe clients appreciate honesty, even when it's not what they initially want to hear. Sometimes protecting a client's interests means telling them no.

<aside class="expert"><img src="https://featured-com-images.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/profile-images/9837a477-9861-44b7-a24b-33a6ba60f0b7.webp" alt="Matthew Goodwin" loading="lazy"><p><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/matt-goodwin-viper-security" rel="nofollow">Matthew Goodwin</a>, Private Investigator, <a href="https://privateinvestigatornh.com" rel="noopener">Viper Security Inc</a></p></aside>

## Related

- [How Lawyers Guide Clients Toward Sounder Legal Decisions](https://lawyermagazine.co/qa/how-lawyers-guide-clients-toward-sounder-legal-decisions.md)
- [Help Legal Clients Choose Wisely on Settlement vs Litigation](https://lawyermagazine.co/qa/help-legal-clients-choose-wisely-on-settlement-vs-litigation.md)
- [How Lawyers Build Client Trust During Difficult Legal News](https://lawyermagazine.co/qa/how-lawyers-build-client-trust-during-difficult-legal-news.md)
- [8 Staffing Strategies That Maximize Efficiency in Growing Boutique Law Firms](https://lawyermagazine.co/qa/8-staffing-strategies-that-maximize-efficiency-in-growing-boutique-law-firms.md)
